Niagara Creamery

Enjoy Your Ice Cream A Bit Differently

Welcome to Niagara Creamery

Niagara Creamery is locally owned and operated by the Paris family who brings their love of ice cream, travel, and supporting the local community together in one place. We are dedicated to providing residents and visitors of Erie and Northwestern PA with a delightful ice cream experience. Our namesake is rooted in Erie’s place in history, ties to the Brig Niagara and its nickname “Gem City” nestled on the shores of Lake Erie.

We offer a variety of classic and exclusive, innovative ice cream flavors, catering to a broad range of tastes, including a non-dairy flavor option. We emphasize customer service, creating a welcoming atmosphere and offering customized options for our delicious treats.

Discover The Icy Delights

From grab-and-go pints, cones, sundaes, ice cream sandwiches, floats, and other varieties of ice cream treats tailored to your liking, we have you covered. We can serve the individual or the largest of groups with our abilities to produce freshly made, hard-packed ice cream right here in Erie, PA.

We are not reselling ice cream you can get anywhere. It’s made right here in Erie, PA and we are making it just for you.

Our Menu

Scoops

Small-batch, Hard Packed Ice Cream
Your choice of a single scoop of our small batch, hard packed ice cream stacked high on a crispy, fresh waffle cones. What could make it any better?

Sundaes

Ice Cream with the Ultimate Toppings
Your choice of a single scoop of our small batch, hard packed ice cream with toppings tailored your way. Pick two toppings or syrups with whipped cream and a cherry on top!

Flagship Flurries

Blended Ice Cream & Candy Delight
Our Vanilla small batch, hard packed ice cream blended to perfection with your favorite topping and served so thick you’ll need to bring your own spoon. Just kidding…we’ll give ya one!

Ice Cream Sandwiches

Homemade Chocolate Chips Cookies
Your choice of ice cream sandwiched between two freshly baked chocolate chips cookies and chilled to perfection!

Roll your sandwich in any of our toppings for just $1.00 more each.

Floats

Soda and Ice Cream
Your choice of ice cream topped off with one of our sodas. We proudly carry Coca-Cola Products.

Slush Puppies

Ice-cold, Sweet Shaved Ice Drink
Nothing takes you back to your childhood like an ice cold Slush Puppie with one of your favorite flavors!

Add a scoop of ice cream to create a Slush Puppie Fusion!

Milkshakes

Made To Order

What flavor are you looking for? You pick it, we shake things up and give you the best milkshake you’ve ever had!

Pints

Powerful Pints Just For You

Some of our best small batch ice cream scooped up and ready to head home with you!

Soft Drinks

Coca-Cola Products (20 oz.)

Ice Cream Flights

Variety Of Tastes

Four 2-ounce scoops of your choice, perfect for sampling multiple flavors in one visit.

Ice Cream Pies

Frozen Dessert

Advanced ordering required. We have 26 flavors of ice cream to choose from. Pies serve 8-10 people. Pick a crust, pick a sauce to line the crust, pick one ice cream, select your topping.

Our Ice Cream

Banana Pudding
Birthday Cake
Black Raspberry Cheesecake
Blue Moon
Butter Pecan
Chocolate
Chocolate Covered Strawberry*
Cinnamon Honey Bun
Coconut Sunset* (Toasted Coconut)
Coffee Oreo
Cookie Dough
Cookies and Cream
Cotton Candy

Dark Chocolate Cherry
Fudge Brownie Blast
Heath Chocolate Chip
Karamel Krunch
Key Lime Pie
Lemon Blueberry Cream Pie
Mint Chocolate Chip
Orange Sorbet**
Oree Dough
Peanut Butter Cup
Pistachio
Rocky Road*
Strawberry
Vanilla

Syrups and Sauces

Carmel
Hot Fudge
Peanut Butter
Marshmallow

Toppings

Butterfinger
Chocolate Chips
Heath Bar
Krunch Kote
M&M’s
Nerds
Oreos
Crushed Peanuts
Pecans
Sprinkles
Strawberry

*New Flavors for 2026 | **Vegan and Non-Dairy

Stop And See Us.

Contact Us

We are proud to announce our catering services! Want a custom quote on icy delights for your next family gathering, birthday party, graduation party, corporate event, or other group activity, call us at (814) 882-2355, email us at niagaracreamery@gmail.com, or use the form below.

← Back