Ice Cream In Erie

Enjoy Your Ice Cream A Bit Differently

Ice cream season at Niagara Creamery is here!

Ice Cream in Erie, PA – Niagara Creamery Homemade Ice Cream – Our 2025 Flavors Below

If you’re searching for the best ice cream in Erie, PA, you’re in the right place. Niagara Creamery proudly serves the Erie community with small‑batch, handcrafted ice cream made from real ingredients, local dairy, and flavors you won’t find anywhere else. Whether you’re visiting the lake, exploring downtown, or just craving something sweet, our ice cream is worth the short trip no matter the reason:

Family outings
Date nights
After‑school treats
Weekend adventures
Lake Erie visitors

Where can I find Niagara Creamery in Erie?

Niagara Creamery is located at:

804 E. 38th Street

What are the seasonal hours at Niagara Creamery?

Our hours are:

Tuesdays and Wednesdays from 3:00pm until 8:00pm
Thursdays from 3:00pm until 8:30pm
Fridays from 2:00pm until 8:30pm
Saturdays from 1:00pm until 8:30pm
Sundays from 1:00pm until 8:00pm
We will be closed on Mondays

Why Erie Loves Niagara Creamery

We’re located just outside Erie, making us a favorite stop for families, students, and ice‑cream lovers looking for something truly homemade.

What sets us apart:

Small‑batch, handcrafted ice cream
Real ingredients — no shortcuts, ever
Rotating seasonal flavors
Family‑owned and community‑focused
Worth the drive from pretty much anywhere

What’s on the menu at Niagara Creamery?

At Niagara Creamery, you will find the following menu items:

Scoops: Locally-made, small-batch, hard-packed ice cream stacked high on crispy, fresh waffle cones. Enjoy flavors like Banana Pudding, Birthday Cake, and Blueberry Muffin.
Sundaes: Ice cream with the ultimate toppings. Choose your toppings or syrups with whipped cream and a cherry on top.
Flagship Flurries: Vanilla ice cream blended with your favorite topping, served thick and delicious.
Ice Cream Sandwiches: Homemade chocolate chip cookies with your choice of ice cream in between. Roll your sandwich in any topping for just $1.00 more.
Floats: Your choice of ice cream topped with one of our sodas. We proudly carry Coca-Cola products.
Slush Puppies: Ice-cold, frozen beverage treat. Add a scoop of ice cream to create a Slush Puppie Fusion.
Milkshakes: Made to order with your choice of flavor.
Pints: Powerful pints of our best small-batch ice cream, ready to take home.
Ice Cream Flights: Four 2-ounce scoops of your choice, perfect for sampling multiple flavors in one visit.
Soft Drinks: Coca-Cola products (20 oz.).